Serious Crackdown Or Just More PR?
Nanaimo Bulletin can tell us how many people police arrested in a two-day shoplifting blitz. Can City Hall tell us what taxpayers are spending to turn downtown around, and what they’re getting for it?
The Nanaimo News Bulletin reported that nearly 20 people were arrested during Operation Jack o’ Lifter on October 19 and 20. The RCMP targeted retail theft in the downtown core and at Port Place Shopping Centre. Officers recovered stolen merchandise. For the merchants who got their stock back, that mattered.
Then the blitz ended. The bills kept coming.
More police officers. Community Safety Officers. Tax concessions to encourage downtown investment. Each commitment carries a cost. Put them together and ask the question City Hall ought to be able to answer in one line. What is the annual cost of the downtown response?
Show us what the city spends on policing and Community Safety Officers downtown. Show us how much property tax revenue the city has forgone through downtown incentives. Then show us what has improved. Are stores reporting fewer thefts? Are the same merchants still getting hit week after week? What are the people who unlock their shops every morning seeing?
That’s what I mean by a black hole for tax dollars. Council can approve one expenditure after another while taxpayers are left to piece together the bill and shopkeepers are left to count their losses.
The RCMP says its retail theft operations since October 2025 have generated 70 criminal investigations, 46 arrests and 44 charge recommendations, along with thousands of dollars in recovered merchandise. How many of those recommendations led to charges? How were the cases resolved? Has repeat theft gone down at the stores these operations were meant to protect?
I remember the press event outside the courthouse years ago. Provincial officials were there, and so were the promises to deal with the revolving door. Those promises made headlines. Today, a merchant who sees someone walk out with a handful of stock still faces a lousy choice. Risk a confrontation or take the loss. Speak up about what’s happening and some customers may decide to shop somewhere else.
There’s another bill we rarely talk about. An industry has grown up around managing the drug crisis, with salaries, contracts and grants that can be renewed year after year. What happens if fewer people are trapped in addiction and fewer need those services? Which contracts would end? How many jobs would disappear? Would governments welcome that as evidence that their policies worked?
I think the province should make mandatory treatment an option in cases where a court finds it warranted and an actual treatment bed is available. Where someone is convicted of repeated theft and the circumstances warrant jail, the courts should be willing to impose it. People struggling with addiction need a route into treatment and recovery. Merchants deserve to see repeat offenders held accountable for the damage they cause.
City Hall and the province should tell us what they spend, how many people get into treatment and stay in recovery, and whether repeat theft is falling. If lasting progress means some programs can shrink, some contracts can end and some jobs are no longer needed, governments should count that as success.
For those of us who remember downtown before Discontent City, the decline has been years in the making. So has the spending meant to reverse it. Council owes taxpayers a full accounting of what it has spent, what it has given up in tax revenue and what Nanaimo has to show for it.
Before council asks taxpayers for another dollar, show us what the last dollar bought. How many people found lasting recovery? How many merchants stopped getting hit? And if the spending has gone up while the same problems keep coming back, why are we being asked to pay for another year of the same?
Comments
Post a Comment
Thank you for your input. Your comment will appear once reviewed.