When a Civic Stage Cancels a Sold-Out Show, Publish the Rulebook
Nanaimo just got a real-time lesson in how “tolerance” gets replaced by pressure.
The Port Theatre Society has cancelled the sold-out March 21, 2026 rental featuring comedian Ben Bankas, saying it came after a “comprehensive review” of contractual and legal obligations and a duty to provide a safe environment for staff, volunteers, patrons, artists, and the community.
This wasn’t a court order. This wasn’t a criminal finding. It was a venue decision—made after public controversy and after City Council urged the theatre to review its booking practices to ensure events align with core values like “accessible, inclusive, and welcoming.”
You can think this performer’s material is crude, insulting, or beneath a civic stage—and still see the danger here.
Because tolerance doesn’t mean “approve.” It means enduring speech you can’t stand without running to the nearest authority to make it disappear. If “tolerance” only covers the views we already agree with, it’s not tolerance. It’s ideology with nicer branding.
And here’s the other point Nanaimo needs to absorb: a sold-out crowd is not proof of a hate movement. The Port Theatre’s main auditorium holds 804 seats. Those 804 ticket holders are not automatically extremists; they’re residents. Some came for the taboo. Some for dark humour. Some out of curiosity. Some because they’re tired of being lectured by the loudest voices in the room. A few may have come for uglier reasons—sure. But smearing the entire audience as moral garbage is how a community becomes brittle and mean.
Now, if the Port Theatre wants to say: “We are not a viewpoint-neutral rental hall; we are a values-curated civic stage,” that is a legitimate choice. But it carries one hard responsibility:
You must publish the standard.
Not a vague statement. Not a moving target. A real, written, consistent set of criteria that can survive the next controversy—no matter which political tribe is shouting.
Because if the rule is “we cancel shows when enough people complain,” then the message to Nanaimo is simple: speech isn’t managed by principle; it’s managed by pressure. And that’s how you get a city that looks polite on the surface, while resentment and distrust grow underneath.
You don’t build a respectful community by banning every offensive voice. You build it by teaching people how to answer bad speech with better speech—and by running public institutions with transparent, consistent standards instead of panic buttons.
The sharp question to the Port Theatre
Exactly what written, viewpoint-neutral criterion did you apply to cancel a sold-out rental—will you publish that criterion in full, and will you list at least five comparable past or future bookings (across differing viewpoints) showing how the same rule is applied consistently, even when the pressure is loud?
Comments
Post a Comment
Thank you for your input. Your comment will appear once reviewed.